Updated October 2026 · Four games played by me; the other five are based on reviews and store pages
I’m not someone who plays horror games all year. But a good one in October is a tradition for me. Here are the four I played myself and can honestly recommend, plus five more that are on my list.
At a glance
| Game | Played by me | Scare level | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy | yes, 13 hours, Xbox Series X | creepy from the middle on | adventure fans who like Tomb Raider |
| A Plague Tale: Requiem | yes, 22 hours, Xbox Series X | dark and grim, rats everywhere | story lovers |
| Alan Wake and Alan Wake 2 | yes, both games | jump scares | psychological thriller fans |
| Dead by Daylight | yes | very scary, in short rounds | playing with friends online |
| Silent Hill f | no | very high | classic survival horror |
| Resident Evil Village | no | high, with action | horror with a lot of shooting |
| Little Nightmares II | no | eerie, not gory | short sessions, puzzle fans |
| DEVOUR | no | jump scares | a co-op Halloween night |
| Alone in the Dark (2024) | not yet – it’s in my drawer | cosmic horror | fans of the 1992 classic |
The four I played myself
1. Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy – my favorite this year
I finished Resonance on Xbox Series X in about 13 hours on normal difficulty. It is a prequel to the Plague Tale games, but you don’t need to know them. Sophia, a young pirate, ends up on the Island of the Minotaur, and the story weaves in Greek myth: Minos, Ariadne, Theseus and the Minotaur itself.
The start feels more like Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag or Tomb Raider than horror. The creepy part comes later: from about the middle, petrified bodies, “zombies” and the Minotaur gave me goosebumps and a few moments where I held my breath. A tip: keep an eye on the blue, shimmering particles. Read my full Resonance review
- Platforms: Xbox Series X|S, PS5, PC
- Game Pass: yes, Ultimate and PC Game Pass
2. A Plague Tale: Requiem – dark, moving, full of rats
Requiem took me about 22 hours on Xbox Series X. It is very dark, but also gripping and moving, with beautiful scenery. The rat swarms are the signature horror of the series: thousands of them on screen, and their glowing eyes stay with you. Some fights drag on a bit, but the story kept me going. Read my Requiem review
- Platforms: Xbox Series X|S, PS5, PC, Switch (cloud)
- Game Pass: no, it left on October 15, 2026
3. Alan Wake – one of my all-time favorites
I played both Alan Wake and Alan Wake 2, and the series is one of my favorites. You play a writer whose novel starts coming true in a small town full of shadows. Light is your weapon: you burn the darkness off enemies with your flashlight before you can fight them. The story grips you from the first chapter, and there are plenty of moments that make you jump.
- Where to start: Alan Wake Remastered (both story add-ons included), then Alan Wake 2
- Platforms: Remastered on Xbox, PlayStation, PC and Switch; Alan Wake 2 on Xbox Series X|S, PS5 and PC
4. Dead by Daylight – horror with friends
Dead by Daylight is the only online game on my list, and I’ve played it myself. One player is the killer, the other four are survivors who repair generators and try to escape. I’ve played it both on my own with strangers and in a group with friends, as killer and as survivor – I enjoy both roles equally. My verdict: very scary. Every Halloween there is a special event.
- Platforms: Xbox, PlayStation, PC, Switch
- Game Pass: yes, Premium and Ultimate
Still on my list: five more horror games
I haven’t played these yet, so this is what reviews and the stores say.
- Silent Hill f (2025): The newest Silent Hill moves the series to 1960s Japan. It is classic, slow-burning survival horror. Xbox Series X|S, PS5, PC.
- Resident Evil Village (2021): First-person horror with a lot of action, set in a snowy village in Eastern Europe. Good if you want to fight back, not just hide.
- Little Nightmares II (2021): A short, eerie puzzle-platformer. It is unsettling rather than gory, so it also works for players who don’t like blood.
- DEVOUR: A co-op horror game for up to four players. Cheap, short rounds, lots of screaming – ideal for a Halloween night with friends.
- Alone in the Dark (2024): A remake of the 1992 original, which is often called the grandfather of survival horror. You explore Derceto Manor in 1920s Louisiana as Emily Hartwood or private detective Edward Carnby. Reviews were mixed: praise for the atmosphere, criticism for clunky combat and bugs. My Xbox Series X copy is still waiting in the drawer – I’ll add my impressions once I’ve played it. Xbox Series X|S, PS5, PC.
Which one should you play?
- You want a story and don’t scare easily: Resonance or Requiem.
- You want jump scares and a mystery: Alan Wake.
- You want to be truly terrified: Silent Hill f.
- You’re playing with friends: Dead by Daylight or DEVOUR.
FAQ
Is Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy a horror game? Partly. It starts as an adventure in the style of Tomb Raider and gets creepy from about the middle.
Which horror games are on Game Pass right now? From this list, Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy is in Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass, and Dead by Daylight is in Game Pass Premium and Ultimate (as of October 2026).
