Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy Review: 13 Hours on Xbox Series X

Updated October 2026 · Played on Xbox Series X with controller · Normal difficulty · Story completed

I finished Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy on Xbox Series X in about 13 hours on normal difficulty. After A Plague Tale: Requiem, I expected more sneaking and rats. Instead I got a pirate adventure full of Greek myth that turns properly creepy halfway through. For me personally, it fits better than Requiem.

My verdict in short

Platform played Xbox Series X, controller
Time to finish about 13 hours, normal difficulty
Best part the story around Greek myth and the Theseus flashbacks
What bothered me a few graphics glitches here and there
Scare level low at first, high from about the middle
Need the earlier games? no
Recommendation yes, especially if you like Black Flag or Tomb Raider

The story: Greek myth meets the Plague Tale world

Resonance is set 15 years before A Plague Tale: Requiem. You play Sophia, whom fans know from Requiem, as a young pirate. After a betrayal she is stranded on the Island of the Minotaur, home to an ancient labyrinth and an old curse.

The story is coherent and exciting, and it draws on Greek mythology: Minos, Ariadne, Theseus and the Minotaur all play a part. How all this connects to Sophia is told really well. I won’t spoil anything here.

The flashbacks to Theseus are a highlight. You play him in ancient Minoan times, and these sections add depth to what happens on the island in Sophia’s time. That is real immersion.

From Black Flag to Tomb Raider: how it plays

At the start, Resonance reminded me more of Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag or Tomb Raider than of the earlier Plague Tale games. The pace and the combat go in that direction too: you fight much more directly with the sword, parry and dodge, instead of mostly sneaking past enemies. In between you solve puzzles with light.

For me personally, that mix fits better than in Requiem, where some fights dragged on.

When does it get scary?

The first half is more adventure than horror. From about the middle, the chills set in. The petrified bodies, the “zombies” and the Minotaur itself made for gripping moments full of goosebumps, where I caught myself holding my breath.

Finding Nemo taught us this long ago: Dory swims through a swarm of jellyfish that shimmer beautifully – until their tentacles sting her. Resonance has its own version. Blue, shimmering particles float through the air and lie on the ground, and later in the game they trigger the Minotaur. Not everything that sparkles is good for your health.

Graphics and technology

On Xbox Series X there were graphics glitches here and there. None of them were bad enough to spoil the game for me.

Do you need to play Innocence and Requiem first?

No. Resonance tells its own story and works on its own. If you know the earlier games, you will spot the connections, and they are woven in nicely.

Where to play it

Resonance came out on August 27, 2026. It is included in Xbox Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass, but not in Game Pass Essential or Premium.

Store Price (October 2026)
Xbox Store (Xbox Series X|S, Play Anywhere) $59.99
PlayStation Store (PS5) $59.99
Steam and Epic (PC) $49.99

Who should play it

  • Yes: You liked Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag or the Tomb Raider games and want a story with myth and mystery.
  • Yes: You have Game Pass Ultimate or PC Game Pass – then it costs nothing extra.
  • Maybe not: You loved the pure sneaking of the first Plague Tale games and don’t want sword fights.

Looking for more to play this autumn? See my list of the best horror games and my A Plague Tale: Requiem review.

FAQ

How long is Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy? It took me about 13 hours on normal difficulty.

Is Resonance on Game Pass? Yes, in Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass.

Is Resonance scary? Not at first. From about the middle, the petrified bodies and the Minotaur create real horror moments.

This Post Has 2 Comments

Comments are closed.